• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to John & John’s - A Pizza Shop

Welcome to John & John’s - A Pizza Shop, located in the heart of Orlando at 435 E Michigan St. This charming eatery specializes in authentic New York-style pizza, praised for its light and crispy crust. Customers rave about the flavor-packed A La Vodka slice, and the friendly service ensures a welcoming atmosphere. Families and friends gather here for not only exceptional pizza but also fresh Greek salads that complement the meal perfectly. The cozy setting, complete with great music, makes every visit memorable. Prepare for a slice of nostalgia and a delightful culinary experience at John & John's!

John & John’s - A Pizza Shop: Reviews & Ratings

Christopher Hames
Christopher Hames

New York feels, we went specialty for our first time and got the A La vodka. Awesome crust, you know, sometimes you just throw it out, light and good. Great service followed with the chef asking how it was personally, love that.

Emily Losada Ortega
Emily Losada Ortega

Simply perfect! The pizzas are incredible, the service is wonderful, and the place is super cozy; even the music is perfect. Highly recommended for family or friends!

Nick
Nick

We just got back from a trip to NYC where NY style pizza reigns supreme. John & John’s knows how to make quality NY pizza and it gave me a little slice of nostalgia for that recent trip up north. Of note, the Vodka slice is packed with flavor and an absolute awesome experience. 10 outta 10! Prices are reasonable, service is quick, flavors are on point, staff is friendly, and the atmosphere is comfortable. I’m thrilled that they’re so close to work because I’m looking forward to future lunches and trying more of their slices.

Josh Keliiheleua
Josh Keliiheleua

The pizza is delicious. The Greek salad is refreshing. A great compliment to your pizza! But the service is why I keep coming back. My kids and wife ate all the olives out of my Greek salad, so when I asked for a few more, the nice young lady behind the counter brought them over to my table with a smile. My go to order here: Upside Down pizza (hold the garlic, for me), Greek Salad, and an Orange Blossom Pilsner in a chilled glass. Chef’s kiss!

Welo and Goldo
Welo and Goldo

Everyone enjoys their Pizza differently. So if I tell you the Pizza is good, you may say “ Forget about it!”. So I will tell you this. The atmosphere was pleasant. The place was very clean. The employees were so hospitable. The pizza was Hot, Fresh and crunchy. I loved it . And by the way , you can fold it up and it doesn’t sag! Hey ... I’m writing here!! I will suggest to give them a try. It will be worth the trip. I hope you will have a very nice experience, like my family and I did.

Alaura
Alaura

PHENOMENAL pizza. Went here cuz it I noticed it while driving. The pizza was super flavorful and the crust was nice & crispy! The appetizer was also really good! The lady working there was so friendly as well. I will be coming here again and recommending this place to others.

Nikki Gonzalez
Nikki Gonzalez

I’ve been coming to John & John’s since they first opened, and they’ve never let me down! After moving to Florida from the Bronx almost three years ago, I’ve tried countless pizza spots in Orlando, but nothing comes close to the quality, flavor, and authenticity of John & John’s Every slice takes me right back home. The crust is always perfectly crispy, the sauce is full of flavor, and the cheese is just right. The staff is friendly, and the consistency is unmatched. If you’re looking for real, top-tier pizza, this is the place to go!

Saied Al
Saied Al

Hands down the best place for New York-style pizza in Orlando! Their pizza is perfectly crispy, cheesy, and full of flavor, just like it should be. The Philly cheesesteak sandwich is absolutely incredible—packed with flavor and cooked to perfection. This place has quickly become my favorite spot for a delicious meal!

Location

Welcome to John & John’s - A Pizza Shop, a culinary gem located in the vibrant heart of Orlando at 435 E Michigan St. If you're on the hunt for authentic New York-style pizza, you've just hit the jackpot. This restaurant combines quality ingredients, a welcoming atmosphere, and exceptional service to create a memorable dining experience that keeps customers coming back for more.

Stepping inside, the cozy ambiance instantly wraps you in a warm embrace, making it a perfect spot for family gatherings or casual hangouts with friends. The thoughtful selection of music complements the vibrant spirit of the shop, enhancing the overall dining experience. Customers rave about the friendly staff, who go above and beyond to ensure each visit feels special. But let’s talk pizza—oh, the pizza!

Drawing inspiration from the streets of New York City, John & John’s offers a diverse menu packed with flavor and creativity. Reviews highlight standout dishes like the A La Vodka pizza, which has been described as "awesome," featuring a perfectly light and crispy crust that invites you to savor every bite. One enthusiastic customer even compared the flavors to a nostalgic trip back to NYC, showcasing just how deeply this pizza resonates with those who know good pie.

For those looking for something unique, the Upside Down pizza is a must-try. This innovative twist has garnered its own fan club, with patrons praising the crunchiness and the sheer delight of its presentation. Complement your pizza with a refreshing Greek salad that adds a delightful crunch and balance to your meal. As shared in glowing testimonials, the service here is remarkable, with staff members like the friendly young lady who personally delivers extra olives with a smile, adding that extra touch to make you feel at home.

John & John’s isn’t just about the food; it’s an experience that captures the essence of community and hospitality. The clean, well-maintained space, combined with hot, fresh pizza that audibly crackles as you take a bite, creates a memorable dining adventure. And let’s not forget the reasonable prices that allow everyone to indulge without breaking the bank.

So, whether you're looking to satisfy a pizza craving or simply enjoy a delightful meal in a welcoming environment, John & John’s - A Pizza Shop is the place to be. Stop by, take a seat, and immerse yourself in a slice of pizza perfection. You won't regret it!